top of page

The Most Sophisticated Holiday Cocktails in New York City

12 hours ago
6 min read

New York City knows how to celebrate the holidays, and its cocktail scene is no exception.


Seasonal cocktails at Leonessa, the rooftop bar at Conrad New York Downtown. Photo courtesy of Leonessa.
Seasonal cocktails at Leonessa, the rooftop bar at Conrad New York Downtown. Photo courtesy of Leonessa.

Meeting friends for a drink after the Rockefeller Center tree? At Saks, the French Onion Soup Martini comes with its own bite of torched Gruyère. Heading downtown for dinner instead? There’s a Turkish espresso cocktail on Jones Street that takes three days to make. From a Midtown piano lounge to a rooftop in Battery Park City, here’s where to pull up a chair in Manhattan this holiday season, and what to order when you do.


Aquavit


Midtown


Golden Pear. Courtesy of Aquavit
Golden Pear. Courtesy of Aquavit

Start dinner at Aquavit with Popped, a nod to the pleasures of a box of movie popcorn. Popcorn and brown butter infuse the aquavit, while soba syrup adds another layer of toasted grain. For a lighter aperitif, Golden Pear pairs Bar Hill gin with Cocchi Americano.

At the other end of dinner, order Velvet Noir. Green walnut liqueur, mint amaro, dark cacao and a touch of candied pecan syrup give this seasonal sour the flavors of a dessert course.


Ayah


SoHo


Courtesy of Ayah
Courtesy of Ayah

Sandalwood smoke greets you before the first sip of The Magic Lamp at Ayah on West Houston Street. Reposado tequila anchors the drink, with Lustau sweet vermouth and fig liqueur lending dark-fruit richness. Cardamom bitters bring a little spice to a cocktail worth lingering over after dinner.


Bar Bas


Hell’s Kitchen


Le Chat Noir. Credit: Bar Bas
Le Chat Noir. Credit: Bar Bas

After a show, slip downstairs beneath Marseille for the house Ninetini. Bar Bas serves the cocktail alongside oysters during its 7–10 p.m. happy hour, a particularly good pairing to have in mind when the curtain comes down.


Chalet Noël Lodge at Printer’s Alley


Times Square


Alpine Rose. Photo by Noel Hatton.
Alpine Rose. Photo by Noel Hatton.

Head downstairs at Printer’s Alley for an après-ski stop near Times Square. Vintage skis set the scene at Chalet Noël Lodge, and the cocktail names carry the theme from the slopes to the table. Look for The Bunny Slope, Alpine Rose, The Black Diamond and Strudel All The Way.


Chito Gvrito


Gramercy


Courtesy of Chito Gvrito
Courtesy of Chito Gvrito

Ask for Askaneli chacha in the Pomegranate Martini at this Georgian restaurant on Third Avenue. The Georgian grape spirit makes a lovely partner for pomegranate and cherry liqueur, though the bar will also make it with vodka. House-made lime syrup sharpens the fruit, and a scattering of ground pink peppercorn perfumes the foam in the chilled coupe. The martini is available from November through January.


Foursome Restaurant & Bar


West Village


Espresso Fortuni. Photo courtesy of Foursome Restaurant & Bar.
Espresso Fortuni. Photo courtesy of Foursome Restaurant & Bar.

Leave room for coffee at this Turkish restaurant on Jones Street. The Espresso Fortuni begins three days ahead, when the bar sets cardamom to steep in vodka. At service, freshly brewed Turkish espresso meets Mr. Black coffee liqueur and cardamom syrup. A final dusting of Turkish coffee and cardamom brings the spice right to your nose as you lift the glass. The cocktail is available through December.


Jac’s on Bond


NoHo


One to watch this season is Club Coquito at Jac’s on Bond. The bar’s forthcoming Nuyorican take on Puerto Rican coquito combines rum, Thai coconut milk and coconut water with ube halaya and pistachio cream. Chai, cinnamon and nutmeg supply the holiday spice. A launch date has yet to be announced.


Le Chalet at L’Avenue at Saks


Midtown


Order the French Onion Soup Martini before dinner and save the bread crisp for your second sip. At this après-ski lounge inside Saks, the bar fat-washes gin with beef tallow and caramelized onion, then serves the martini with a caramelized onion garnish and a crisp topped with torched Gruyère. The holiday run began November 20. Go on a weekend for live piano.


Leonessa


Battery Park City


Oliva Martini. Courtesy of Leonessa
Oliva Martini. Courtesy of Leonessa

Up on the roof of Conrad New York Downtown, the Noci Old Fashioned pairs Maker’s Mark with sherry, Averna and walnut, finished with a twist of orange. For a savory first round, try the Oliva Martini with vodka, gin, dry vermouth, bergamot and olive. Sherry also turns up in the Margarita d’Autunno, where it joins reposado tequila, Sarti Rosa, agave and lime.


Limo Bar


East Village


The Plaza Highball. Credit: Wrk The Room
The Plaza Highball. Credit: Wrk The Room

The Lost in NYC holiday pop-up takes over a bar modeled on a 1980s limousine. Settle in for The Plaza Highball, a long pour of tequila, mango and sparkling water finished with nutmeg. It’s a refreshing pick before a rich dinner, with just enough spice to suit the season. The highball is on the menu from November 18 through January 3.


Little Opus


Midtown


Midwinter Muse. Photo by Alex Phillips.
Midwinter Muse. Photo by Alex Phillips.

On West 46th Street, bartender Aurelio Rojas takes inspiration from Lady Whistledown for the Midwinter Muse. Beneath the floral garnish is a tart combination of vodka, cranberry and lemon, with Cointreau adding a note of orange. Little Opus plans to serve it all winter.


Maison Close


SoHo


Courtesy of Maison Close
Courtesy of Maison Close

If mezcal is your usual order, try the Mademoiselle Seguin at Maison Close. The surprise in this French restaurant’s cocktail is goat cheese. Fresh lemon plays up its tang, while raw honey infused with thyme picks up the herbal notes of Marie Brizard anisette. Beneath it all is the smoke of Del Maguey Vida mezcal.


The Mark Chalet


Upper East Side


Make an evening of Swiss fondue on Madison Avenue. At The Mark Chalet, order mulled wine to sip between bites, or settle in with a hot toddy. This is the stop to choose when the plan calls for something warm in both the pot and the glass.


New York Central Restaurant and Bar


Midtown East


Winter Berry Fizz. Courtesy of Hyatt Grand Central
Winter Berry Fizz. Courtesy of Hyatt Grand Central

The Winter Berry Fizz at Hyatt Grand Central is a reason to pause before catching your train. Vanilla cold foam caps a bright mix of vodka, white cranberry, elderflower, lemon and soda. Sugared cranberries and rosemary finish the December special.


Odd Sister


SoHo


Amber Thread. Photo courtesy of Odd Sister.
Amber Thread. Photo courtesy of Odd Sister.

After an afternoon on Mercer Street, head to No. 45 for Amber Thread, head bartender David Sheeran’s take on mulled wine. Malbec and sloe gin give the cocktail its dark fruit, hibiscus adds a tart floral note, and cacao brings out the deeper flavors in the wine. Odd Sister expects to pour it until around February.


O’Toole’s Way


Hudson Yards


Credit: IGC Hospitality
Credit: IGC Hospitality

A tiny wreath adorns Sloggin’ the Nog at O’Toole’s Way. Inside the glass, Yoshi matcha liqueur brings an earthy tea note to the familiar pairing of eggnog and Bacardi spiced rum. Order it for dessert after an evening in Hudson Yards. It’s available through the holiday season.


Pebble Bar


Midtown


Credit: Melissa Robotti
Credit: Melissa Robotti

A few steps from Radio City Music Hall, duck into Pebble Bar’s nineteenth-century townhouse for A Study in Scarlet. Hibiscus gives this fall cocktail its color. Calvados and Angostura bitters recall spiced apple cider, then pineapple and lime take it somewhere sunnier. Elyx vodka, Suyo pisco and Sarti Rosa aperitivo round out the drink.


With a few friends at the table, try Three Caballeros for reposado tequila, Ancho Reyes, spiced pear and ginger. Thai Me to the Moon is a clarified blend of bourbon and coconut rum with Yellow Chartreuse, basil eau de vie, cinnamon, lime and chile oil. For the coffee drinker, The Ginger Baker folds cold brew, blackstrap rum, rye and amaretto into an egg-white sour with ginger, lemon and bitters.


Somewhere Nowhere


Chelsea


Courtesy of Somewhere Nowhere
Courtesy of Somewhere Nowhere

Eight heated rooftop igloos offer a view of the Empire State Building. For a sparkling first round, try the Spiced 75, with gin, lemon, chai-honey, elderflower and sparkling wine. Orchard & Ash is the pick for cider lovers, pairing cognac and reposado tequila with cider, lemon and caramelized apple.


Velvet Chai brings together vodka and oat milk. Marshmallow Hour goes a little further into dessert, finishing rum, hazelnut, dark chocolate and espresso with a torched marshmallow. Pear & Spice and Blossom Hour give guests two spirit-free choices.


ZOI Mediterranean


NoMad


Courtesy of ZOI Mediterranean
Courtesy of ZOI Mediterranean

For a first drink before dinner in NoMad, order Meet You in Istanbul. ZOI Mediterranean infuses gin with chamomile, then adds Italicus, agave and lemon. The gentle floral notes make this an especially appealing order for anyone who likes a citrusy gin cocktail.




Stay in the Know

bottom of page